Join us to Seek Justice for Mir Murtaza Bhutto

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Literary Event Update via Twitter

desianwar @FBfanclub Fatima Bhutto and I had indepth discussion on her life/writings at literary lunch during Ubud Writer's Festival in Bali, today.


Today's Literary Lunch With FB (picture update)

Credit :http://twitter.com/desianwar

Saturday, October 10, 2009

Pakistanis Favour the GOP

OffTheBus recently caught up with Fatima Bhutto, Benazir Bhutto's niece, whose father died under questionable circumstances at the hands of the police force under her aunt's rule.



Fatima Bhutto is 25-years-old, a newspaper columnist/author and, in the eyes of many, the crown princess of Pakistan's most powerful political dynasty. She is the granddaughter of the late Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, Pakistan's wildly popular former prime minister (who was hanged after a military takeover by General Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq). Fatima is also the niece of Benazir Bhutto, the county's past and would-be future prime minister.

Aunt Benazir is back under house arrest again and calling for Musharraf to quit. Yet, when Fatima talked to me from Karachi, she had a lot to say about her aunt's extravagant political gamesmanship, about how Pakistanis will react if the U.S. attacks Iran, about which American presidential candidate looks like a winner from a Pakistani standpoint---and which Dem she personally wants to see win. [Hint: It's not Hillary].

OffTheBus: How has the Bush Administration affected Pakistani politics?

Fatima Bhutto: A lot. Musharraf has been fighting the war on terror for the Bush White House, as if it was his own, and so he's brought it to our doorstep. Prior to 9/11 and the war on terror, the religious parties in Pakistan really had no ground support. Out of 400 seats in parliament, they would take maybe four or five. They would never break double digits. But after 9/11, and after opening up our borders to American forces, and launching airstrikes, the religious right has tripled or quadrupled their support. Instead of getting four seats, they get 15 or 20 seats. And now we have a civil war going on in the northern part of our country.

OffTheBus: As you know, the US will elect a new president. Do Pakistanis pay much attention to American politics? And if so, who would they like to see in office?

FB: Actually, Pakistanis follow American elections very closely, because they affect us so much. But, if you ask most Pakistanis, they believe earnestly that Republicans are the best, because they'll give us a lot of money, aide and weapons. The average person forgets that, in return, we have to do the American's dirty work for them. I think what a lot of people are most upset about is right now is that Americans are threatening to cut aid. The average Pakistani doesn't think about what we have to do to get that money.

OffTheBus; What about you? Who do you like?

FB: I have to say I like Obama a lot. His record is the best. He's always been vocal about his opposition to the war in Iraq. And he's speaking out against the Patriot Act. Frankly, he seems very good in a lot of ways. Whereas with Hillary, if you look at her record, it doesn't support what she says now. If I could vote in the American elections, Obama would get my vote.

But even Obama has come out and said, if necessary, we will attack Pakistan. They've all said that -- Republicans and Democrats. So Pakistanis feel the safest bet is the Republicans, because they will fund us and give us those F-16s that we paid for and never got. As, for the religious parties, they like the neocons because they lose a lot of their dynamism if they have no one to go up against. For them, the neocons are perfect.

***************************************************************************************************************


To understand the magnetic force the name "Bhutto" conjures in Pakistan, imagine the Kennedys, the Clintons and the entire Bush clan all rolled into one -- with added doses of tragedy, corruption and political intrigue. It's important to know that Fatima's father, Murtaza Bhutto, was an opposition member of parliament when older sister Benazir was last in power, and that he died in a hail of bullets under still-cloudy circumstances at the hands of the police force under his sister's rule. Then later, Benazir retreated into exile amid big-money corruption charges that Musharraf has recently agreed to drop.

You also need to know that Columbia-educated Fatima is widely expected to leap into politics herself. But, if and when she ever does, it will assuredly not be under her aunt's Pakistani People's Party banner.
***************************************************************************************************************
OffTheBus: A lot of people have called for you to run for public office? Are you seriously considering it?

FB: Well, I don't believe my name automatically qualifies me, or makes me the best person. In a country like Pakistan where is politics is often an art form of the elite, and it's often very dynastic, it's hard to explain to people why I don't think it's a birthright. But no, I'm not going to run for elections this January or February whenever Musharraf claims its going to happen. I'd only do it if I felt I could make a positive difference. But, I feel like writing is best for now.

OffTheBus: And in the future?

FB: I'm very political in my writing. And I'm politically active in other ways. I think we can build democracy in Pakistan. But it will take time. And it will be a Pakistani democracy. Not one that's imposed by....someone else.

OffTheBus: Speaking of political impositions, how would Pakistanis react if Bush were to attack Iran?

FB: I think it would be catastrophic. If our government sides with an American attack on Iran, that'll be it. The Pakistani people have great sympathy for the Iranian people. We don't think we're anything like the Afghans. We don't think we're like the Iraqis, really either. But Pakistanis and Iranians have a connection. Urdu is very much like Farsi. It's practically the same language.

I visited Iran last January. And I asked Iranians what they would do if there was an American strike. And they said, "We'd strike America back." I asked how they could do that. And they said, "Don't you realize, we'll strike them in Afghanistan, we'll strike them in Iraq, and we'll strike them in Pakistan." Really, it would be catastrophic.

OffTheBus: Now that your aunt's again under house arrest, and has ratcheted up her calls for General Musharraf to step down, the media is reporting that the Bush-brokered power sharing deal between her and the general is now off.

FB: A lot of this is theater. Actually, it seems very much still on. Her corruption cases remain withdrawn -- as per the arrangements of the deal. all her supporters and her party members are allowed into the compound with her. She addresses her supporters outside through a megaphone. And she is granted amazing access to the media here, while other political parties have been given a blanket ban. If they want to hold a press conference they're not allowed. Only the Islamic party is given similar freedoms. And it isn't Benazir's supporters getting arrested by the thousands. It's the lawyers who have been charged with treason, and the journalists.

OffTheBus: So why her latest surge in rhetoric?

FB: I think she's in a tight spot. Her party supporters want her to come out more directly against Musharraf and she's flip flopped. It seems, though, that Musharraf's camp is tiring of her. One of his cabinet members just gave a statement saying she is the least suitable candidate for Prime Minister. But then again they never wanted her in the first place. She was forced upon them by the White House.

It's a murky situation here. Unfortunately it only gets murkier by the minute.

OffTheBus: Ever since emergency rule was declared, much of the media has been shut down. So how is everyone managing to get news?

FB: Well, this is the 13th emergency that's been declared in Pakistan's sixty-year history. So we pretty much know the drill. But the media has suffered tremendously since this emergency. The journalistic community was accused of betraying the country. A media law was passed almost immediately, which states that broadcasters can no longer give opinions about Pakistan. No live scenes of conflict can be aired on TV anymore. Now, we no longer know who is protesting, who is in danger. Stations can be shut down at any time. No foreign airtime is allowed. So we don't have CNN or the BBC anymore... And we can't even get podcasts. We're proud of the fact that we're part of the information age. Cutting that off has jolted people, especially the young people.

OffTheBus: Okay, then what methods do you use to get the word out?

FB: They haven't been able to block our email providers like Hotmail. Blogs are also very useful for notifications about protests and arrests. And we get a lot of news from text messaging. The government thought that this media blackout would deprive us of the news, but somehow we're very resourceful people.

OffTheBus: You lost your father when you were fourteen years old....

FB: Yes. He was assassinated in a very violent way. We read about assassination squads in the paper every day. Violence is so cheap in Pakistan. But when it happens to your father, you have a different stake in it. He was killed right outside our house. And I went to the hospital so I saw him in that... state. I don't know that we'll ever get justice in my father's case. Too many people have too much to lose.

OffTheBus: Were you close to your father?

FB: I was very, very close to my father. My biological mother and he were divorced when I was very young. And he didn't marry my stepmother -- who is really my mother --until years later. So my father raised me as a single parent until I was almost seven. So we were sort of bachelors in exile. It was my father who brushed my hair, and took me to school and did my homework with me. It was very progressive, I think. He was the first one to notice that I enjoyed writing. He gave me the foundation that I stand on now. He was the best.

OffTheBus: When it comes to writers, who are you heroes?

FB: Robert Fisk. I remember reading his book when I was eighteen and going off to college, and thinking, I want to be like him and be a journalist. Seymour Hersh. He's another person. My favorite poet is T.S. Elliott. I love writers from the Jazz Age. I love Fitzgerald. I'm a very proud bookworm. I just read The History of Love by Nicole Krauss. It's beautiful, beautiful writing.

OffTheBus: You're very critical of both the Musharraf government, and of your aunt. Are you ever fearful about your own safety?

FB: Well, yes... I've been very vocal in my columns, and sometimes I've been told, "You could be hurt if you're not careful." But it always comes in the form or a friendly warning and not a direct threat. (pause) But I take precautions.

Source:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/


Fatima Bhutto on Writing

‘Can everyone become a writer’, Fatima Bhutto said at the Jaipur Literary Fest (early 2008)

‘the best writing is honest and true, by opening your mind and heart to a topic and letting it take you to places and feeling that you weren’t prepared for, you create good work. If that can be taught then that’s wonderful”

Source:http://mochawritersclub.blogspot.com

Katcha Garhi

By Fatima Bhutto
The News, June 10, 2007

On the outskirts of Peshawar lies Katcha Garhi, one of the first Afghan refugee camps established in Pakistan. Katcha Garhi, set up months after the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979, is home to almost 100,000 refugees and is one of the largest camps inside Pakistan. Escaping more than two decades of war, both civil and international, has been no easy feat for the Afghan people. More than one million Afghans were killed, millions more maimed and crippled by carpet bombing operations and landmines (an estimated 15 million of which were planted under Afghan earth), and approximately six million people – one fifth of the pre-war population – were turned into refugees. In the 1980s it was said that one out of every two displaced people in the world was an Afghan.

Roughly four million Afghans came to Pakistan in search of refuge, half of them living in the many camps that were set up along the fringes of our cities. This year, the Pakistan government plans to close four of the largest camps, including Jalozia, Girdi Jungle, and Jungle Pir Alizai, and by doing so encourage the repatriation of 1.5 million Afghan refugees. The residents of Katcha Garhi do not get a full year, they have until next Friday – June 15 – to pack their bags and evacuate their homes. They have five days to return to a land they had left for dead.

Repatriation programmes, initiated by the government and aided by UNHCR, have been underway since 2002. Around 2.8 million refugees have been relocated in the past five years but it hasn't been an easy sell. The government is currently offering $60 a head (this includes a travel allowance) to repatriate and in many cases, families will take the money and leave Pakistan through one checkpoint only to re-enter through another border point a few months later, resettling in the homes they had pretended to desert. The authorities of Katcha Garhi have since caught on and the camp is now being bulldozed meter by meter to ensure that by next week there will be nothing left to call home, a pre-emptive measure to guarantee permanent repatriation. On May 15 twelve families took their belongings and left Katcha Garhi – their homes were bulldozed hours after they had locked their doors for the last time. This time, there will be no return.

The residents of Katcha Garhi are not new to Pakistan, they are second or third generation refugees. They may not have intended to settle in Pakistan, but every passing year brought only more conflict and warfare to their country, so they stayed. Each house in Katcha Garhi holds approximately 18-20 people. I saw eleven people file out of one cramped house myself. They could not walk side by side in the alleyways outside their home, there was no space. The alleys are three feet wide and lined with rotting garbage and snaking gutters; by any stretch of the imagination, Katcha Garhi cannot look very different from war-torn Afghanistan.

It is a town within a town – there is a school run by refugees that educates girls in the morning and boys in the afternoon, a vegetable market, a UN medical centre, and a local jirga that handles the resident's disputes. The police don't come around xhere very often. It seems that no one does. As I'm talking to a group of young boys, a man comes up to me and sticks his registration card in my face and starts rattling off in Pushto. He thought I was a UNHCR official and began complaining about his wife's medical problems in rapid fire Pushto, eager not to leave anything out. Even after I explained, through one of the young boys who translated, that I was not a UN employee the man followed me around pointing at his ID card and making pained hand gestures.

Fazle Rehman, one of the boys who vouched for my non-UN status, is a student in the third grade. He is fourteen years old. He was wearing a pair of dark black sunglasses and carrying around his schoolbooks. His father is a daily wager and his mother a housewife. Along with his five sisters and two brothers, Fazle Rehman was born in Katcha Garhi. He's never been to his home in Kabul and says that one day, when things are better, he'd like to return to Afghanistan. I don't have the heart to tell him that he's going to be back sooner than he thinks, much before things are better. As we walk and talk, the man with the ID card interjects, 'there are no facilities here, no security'. It's probably my pen and paper that have blown my cover and I nod and write down whatever he says to me through the translator. I may not be with the UN, but I'm not deaf and what he has to say is troubling, so I listen.

They don't want to leave, not like this he says. Many of them have lost their families in Afghanistan; they don't have anything to return to. He says he has made his home here, in this dusty refugee camp, and that it's here where he earns his livelihood as a labourer in nearby Hayatabad where even the billboards are in Dari Persian.

It's a no-win situation. Pakistan cannot afford to shelter millions of refugees for much longer and Afghanistan is not able to care for its existing citizens, let alone its exiled citizenry. Undoubtedly, Pakistan has been infinitely kinder to its population of Afghan refugees than Iran was. When in Tehran earlier this year, a woman dealing with the UN repatriation project there told me that due to inflation and umemployment it became illegal, literally a crime, to employ an Afghan in the Iranian workforce. In Iran they existed in the underbelly of society, biding their time until it ran out and they were chased out of yet another country. I want to tell the man with the ID card that, I want to tell him that we've tried to be good to him and his family but that in some government office in Islamabad it's been decided that the effort is no longer sustainable. But we tried…I really believe we did try. No one is listening to me, however. I haven't spoken since arriving in the camp, everyone is talking to me and since I can do nothing more than listen, I do just that.

As I'm on my way out of the camp, on my way back to a comfortable house in Peshawar, a young boy sidles up to me and says in English "How are you?" He's nervous, I can tell. Speaking English is a great deal here and all the other children around us are aware of his enviable ability to do so. I tell him that I'm fine and ask his name. He tells me his name is Jahanzeb. A beautiful name. I ask him if he knows what it means and he shakes his head. Someone who loves the world, I tell him and he looks at me unmoved. In retrospect it was a stupid thing to say, to tell a boy living in a refugee camp that his name means someone who loves the world.

I asked Jahanzeb what he wants to be when he grows up and he hesitated in answering me. "What can I be? I can't do anything here in Pakistan". Jahanzeb speaks Farsi, Pushto, Urdu, and English. He is ten years old. I told him he could be anything he wanted.

After thinking for a moment, he said "I'd be a doctor" and smiled.

Ubud Readers and Writers Festival 2009 Update

Desy Nurhayati and Katie Lamb

A discussion about writers' views on the United States President Barack Obama and on the Middle East peace process stole the show during the third day of the annual Ubud Writers and Readers Festival on Friday.

Speaking at the discussion were Benazir Bhutto's niece, Fatima Bhutto, Australian author Anthony Loewenstein and novelist Jamal Mahjoub, whose works have been widely translated and received several awards.

Delving into the world's hottest war zones was never going to be solved in an hour-long discussion, but what panelists did was to dissect the rhetoric from the reality of Obama's much-hyped potential for global change.

Fatima Bhutto said Obama - who was named on Friday as this year's Nobel Peace Price laureate - had yet to bring changes in Pakistan and Afghanistan because the US would still add more troops.

Similar sentiments came from Anthony Loewenstein, author of My Israel Question, who just got back from a trip to Palestine. He said things had never been worse in the West Bank.

Even novelist Jamal Mahjoub, the most optimistic among the panelists conceded that perhaps the power of Obama was largely as a symbol rather than a testament to change.



Source: The Jakarta Post

The Bhutto legacy in a younger generation

Antony Loewenstein

During my current visit to Indonesia, I’ve been spending time with Fatima Bhutto, the niece of assassinated Pakistani politician Benazir Bhutto. Fatima is a determined, passionate person, angry at her government’s complicity with the US and its war against supposed “terrorists”.

Here’s a short extract from a 2008 Guardian profile:

Fatima is at great pains to distance herself from her aunt. She did her masters at London’s School of African and Oriental Studies, not Oxford, she points out, and instead of heading a debating society, she wrote her dissertation on the resistance movement to Zia. She published a book of poetry, Whispers of the Desert, at the precocious age of 15, followed in 2006 with a collection of stories about the 2005 earthquake that killed 73,000 people in Kashmir and North West Frontier Province. “The comparisons are largely cosmetic,” she said. “In terms of political ideology, what we read, how we think, we are very different. I don’t think that I’m anything like her.”

Her weekly column touches on social and political issues. She won plaudits for her reports of the 2006 war in Lebanon – she was in the country when the fighting started – and keeps a poster of Hizbullah leader Hassan Nasrallah on the door of her office. She yearns to visit Kabul, her birthplace, but her mother discouraged it on grounds of danger.


Source: http://antonyloewenstein.com

Highlights from Friday at the Ubud Writers and Readers Festival

Katie Jacobs

I started the day in the intimate Left Bank Lounge for a session called 'Wanderlust: Travelling stories". The first panelist was Andrew McMillian, a rock journalist from Darwin, who has spent a large amount of time living with Australian Aboriginal communities in the Western Desert and Northern Territory. He had some fascinating insights into a little understood group gained travelling within his own country.The second was Lee Su Kim, A Chinese Malaysian (Baba-Nyonya) who discussed studying in Texas and the peculiarities of being an 'alien of colour' in the USA.

The final panelist Brian Thacker was very funny. He has made a career out of absurdist travel, e.g. writing a book on travelling to five countries simply based on the fact he had never heard of them (and not researching anything before he departed) and 'Sleeping Around' chronicling his adventures while travelling the world with the website couchsurfing.org where people open their homes and their couches to travellers for free.

My final session later in the day was a complete contrast and turned out to be particularly topical. 'Writing in the new world: Obama and Dissent' discussed the importance of continuing critical analysis and dissent within the media. It featured Fatima Bhutto, a journalist from Pakistan, Antony Loewenstein, a political journalist from Sydney and Jamal Mahjoub, a novelist from London by way of Sudan debating whether Obama has so far failed to live up to his promise through a lack of concrete actions or whether his message of hope and change and the very fact of his reaching the presidency is the main thing and the importance of continuing dissention even given, or perhaps because of, his worldwide popularity.

On a side note I happened to be in the same venue as these writers when the news came through that Obama had won the Nobel Peace Prize which drew some fairly heated opinions from the participants.

Source: http://beattiesbookblog.blogspot.com

Friday, October 9, 2009

Ubud Readers and Writers Festival 2009 Day 3

Oh, Oh, Obama.

Coming to Ubud, Bali, after three months in Jakarta has made me slightly nauseaus. I hardly take my sunglasses off, and not because the light is harsh. The light is like syrup, the air clean and moist, the world a verdant, indecent green. My third day here and I still try not too look too hard at things in case I notice that it’s all just a joke: that there are seams in trees where they’ve been recently erected. That if I touch the plants my hands will come away with paint on them. That the still, crumbling buildings are cardboard cut outs. I leave my sunglasses on because I’m scared of the disappointment I’ll feel if I take them off and find that I’m not in the world, but in an adult, Bali-Disney set.

But I’ll write of the strangeness of Ubud later. Because I have Obama on my mind.

About an hour ago I got out of a session at the wonderful Ubud Writers and Readers Festival with the sort of manic frustrated energy that ideas should give you. Remembering all the reasons why politics is everything: because politics is people.

The session was called Writing in the New World: Obama and Dissent. Hosted by Michael Vatikiotis from the Humanitarian Durant Centre for Dialogue in Geneva, the panelists included Antony Lowenstein — who wrote My Israel Question a while ago in Australia and set off a spate of angry press – eloquent novelist Jamal Mahjoub, and Fatima Bhutto, niece of former Pakistani Premier Benazir Bhutto.

The panel was superbly moderated. I’ve only been to a couple of sessions here but, as with all the writer’s festivals I’ve ever been to, they’ve often suffered from lack of competent moderation.

And if there was anything that could have killed this session it would have been a bad moderator. The enormous, open marble hall where it was held perched on the edge of a ravine was packed, the audience full of maniacally twitching listeners who, as the panel went on, began to mutter and twist in their chairs, bite at nails and wind cheap batiks into knots. The middle aged women behind me started low rants half way through, as if the bottled political frustration of years was rising on their breaths like a stench. Snorting and exhaling rank disappointment and dissent, maybe more with themselves than the world.

The theme that arose from the panel was the need to criticize and watch Obama for faults. That the promise of Obama and the symbolism of his presidency was new, but that the world he was inheriting was old. Bhutto spoke again and again of the wrongs the American administration continues to perpetuate on the world and the danger of letting what she called ‘Obama-mania’ blind us to them. Dissent is not disloyalty, she kept repeating.

I could see that many people disagreed. What about, they were shifting, what about what about. What about the other people we should hold to account. Whose fault is this really? Can’t we enjoy this rhetoric? Can’t we enjoy this moment? Haven’t we won, somehow? Give him time, people kept repeating: give Obama time to realize all the things we need from him.

Their disappointment was endless, and their hope new and fragile, and you could feel the edges of despair moving in against the wall-less room as the panel went along.

For a moment, Obama’s election was a reprieve from the endless battle of politics. It’s been proof, to so many people, myself included, of the possibility of change. A visual reminder of the wonder and plasticity of human society.

What I wonder at is that anyone could ever think that was enough. The disappointment and anger that was already palpable in the high, luridly verdant hills of Ubud today was sad, not because it showed a lack of faith, but because it showed a lack of understanding of what democracy and politics are.

William Hastie, the first African-American judge on a Federal court of appeals, once said that ‘Democracy is not being, it is becoming. It is easily lost, but never finally won.’

Obama’s election isn’t the end, but just another beginning. And I wondered at the woman who stood up and asked a wonderful question but who qualified it with ‘…but I’m only a normal person.’ I wondered who exactly she thought politics was about, and who it was meant to be for.

The question no one answered was asked by a skinny, earnest US college student, who thanked the panel for dealing critically with Obama and fumbled with her microphone. And the question was this: what can we do to rectify the blunders continuous American administrations have made in the world?

Everyone laughed, the whole room, as if she’d asked something stupid, something naive. They took another question straight away, and answered that instead. I felt bad for the sloping back of her head and the way she looked around at everyone else in the room, wondering if anyone was going to bring it up again, beginning to blush and cringe as she realized that the conversation had moved away.

Because in the end, asking what we should do, what we can do is the best, the most responsible, the most fundamental of all political questions.

source:http://rubyjoymurray.wordpress.com

Ubud Readers and Writers festival 2009 Day 3

The Ubud Writers’ and Readers’ Festival has managed to pull in a number of interesting people over the years, some with overwhelmingly political backgrounds. This year is no exception, with Nobel Laureate Wole Soyinka and Fatima Bhutto in the line-up.

As journalist-turned-arbitrator Michael Vatikiotis commented, the UWRF has become something of a writer’s talk show. There is a tendency for the audience/participants to expect the enlightened sound bite from the panel, and there is of course the reciprocal tendency to be absolutely charming and witty in return. But those are more the sideshows.

With a bit of luck one gets to sit in on discussions that truly open one’s mind to other points of view presented eloquently. Not that one has to agree, but it is always of value to have a different perspective or even a challenge to one’s complacently held ideas.

Today’s discussion on Obama and the “honeymoon” from the perspective of novelist Jamal Mahjoub, journalist Antony Loewenstein, and journalist/writer Fatima Bhutto was something of an example. The latter, who lost her father and aunt to political violence, had a very skeptical view of Obama’s achievement of all that was promised during his meteoric campaign. As a Pakistani, her assessment of Obama is perhaps understandable in the light of the increased ‘droning’ – predators of death hanging over so much of her country – and the incessant trips by US envoy Holbrooke telling Pakistan what to do.

She was joined by Loewenstein, whose dissenting cum apologist Jewish take on the state of Israel’s aggressive sabotage of the peace process has been hardened by much direct observation of what actually goes on in Palestine. Talking about the two states within Palestine concept, he saw no possibility of the US sponsored concept to ever materialize. This largely because he saw how aggresively and flagrantly the Israelis continue to violate the West Bank, . It seems Obama is, for him, a kind of icing on a very bitter cake.

Mahjoub on the other hand was a little more aligned to the Obama friendly crowd. Obama is an important symbol of change, he argued, and Obama’s rhetoric is important. I think everyone agrees it’s a damn sight better than Bush’s.

Personally I feel that expecting Obama to right all of the dysfunctional US foreign policy legacy in 9 months is naïve at the very best. But far worse than that is the tendency to overlook the fact that civic movement and dissent should address itself to the rot and insidious players who are the obstacles to Obama’s vision and hopes that he expresses in his ‘rhetoric’. Both those for and against this embattled man in Washington are creating impossible benchmarks for him. Give the man a few more months!

Super liberal members of his own party seem to have cornered him into tackling the toughest political stumbling block of all US presidents, the health care debacle, far too early in his term. His detractors are watching with glee, whilst at the same time quietly preparing more obstacles to prevent him exorcising the dark and arcane phantoms of power that haunt the US capital’s political corridors.

His attempt at reaching out across the aisle are reflected in his foreign policy diplomacy. Here too his ambitious efforts at diplomacy is dangerously exposed to defeat as the big hustlers in real politik (not least the US military machine) hunker down for a long battle for influence over US foreign policy. He is being pushed perilously close to fatal commitment in Afghanistan. Israel is playing hardball on the West Bank despite stern reminders. And Iran is a nasty itch that could turn into a dangerously infected tropical ulcer.

So when (ok, if) Obama fails to attain these impossible benchmarks, and his critics gather for the kill, what will have happened? Once again the true villains of the system will have eluded attention. And this is really my main objective to Bhutto’s and Lowenstein’s skepticism – by being cynical about Obama we are missing the point.

Putting aside all vicarious chauvinistic sentiments (after all Obama lived in my chiukldhood district of Jakarta), I feel it is very special that Obama won a free election as a man of colour in a country where less than half a century ago a black man, Martin Luther King, was very publicly assasinated simply because he had a dream of having equal rights as a white man. That in itself is an extraordinary achievement, and of enormous significance. On top of that, as Mahjoub pointed out, he did it without getting himself into debt with Big Business – basically the people financed his victory. He has become a true leader, and at the same time an easy target. In reality, the whole world voted for him.

An eerie sense of the twilight zone came over me when an hour after this public discussion, my mobile vibrated with the messages of Obama’s Nobel prize. I was incredulous at first, and then apprehensive. To have been nominated in February meant that he was only two weeks into office. Quite obviously the Nobel Prize committee has it’s own political agenda. But now, yet again, Obama has been handed a very sharp double edged sword.

While theoretically it might give him more clout, it seems that this is exactly the kind of speculation that an academic committee locked up in an ivory tower would come up with. Outside, the wolves in the realpolitik landscape wait and prowl. Will they focus on the dead, rotten meat in the system? Or are they too fond of living flesh? Will the people in the US take the “people’s revolution” a step further and actually unite against all the pernicious Washington lobbyists et al? Should the Nobel prize committees have psychological evaluation/their heads examined regularly?

Meanwhile, back in Ubud, it’s party time for the writers.

Source :http://www.riohelmi.com/site/?p=666

UBUD WRITERS & READERS FESTIVAL 2009 Day2

Katie Jacobs

Today, Thursday was the first full day of discussion and panels. All day I continued to be caught by surprise by attending sessions full of intense dialogue and questioning and the juxtaposition of spilling out into the winding tropical streets of Ubud, dropping away into jungle-filled ravines. It is a very special event.

After the keynote speech by Michael Bliss, a representative of the Australian Embassy, who extolled the continued compassion and solidarity expressed by Australia towards Indonesia and its people, the first major session was entitled "The Future of Compassion" featuring Wole Soyinka from Nigeria, the number one star of the festival and the first Nobel laureate from Africa and Seno Gumira Ajidarma, an Indonesian journalist and writer who has long challenged the social and human rights injustices which have occurred within Indonesia, infamously with regard to East Timor.

The session was very political and argued definitions and boundaries of compassion by those who have had more extreme situations in which to apply it than most. There were also lighter notes, most notably with Mr Soyinka commenting on Australia's "lack" of compassion in asking him to fill out extra visa forms of a personal nature due to his 70 years of age.


In a much more intimate setting, The Left Bank Lounge, three writers, Arnold Zable Mohan,(pic left with Vinita Ramani Mohan),from Australia, Clara Ng from Indonesia and Vinita Ramani Mohan from Singapore discussed "The Role of Storytelling".
The discussion was of a much more literary nature from the previous ones and focused on the storyteller as a conduit including responsibility to those whose stories you are telling.
I was particularly impressed by Arnold Zable and his writings in this session. He is the son of Yiddish holocaust survivors and grew up (and still lives) in Melbourne. He has been collecting stories his whole life from his surrounding ethnic communities which form the basis of his fiction. He described the care he takes in working with them to make sure he is correctly representing them and their stories in his books. (To quote Mr Zable S=ER squared, or Story equals Entry into a Relationship over a period of time.)

In the afternoon, in a standing room only restaurant, I attended "A conversation with Fatima Bhutto and Bejan Matur" (who actually identifies as Alevi Kurdish rather than Turkish as I described her in an earlier post). This was another intense conversation with two young women who lead very political lives, choosing to serve as witnesses and reporters of their cultures, countries and communities.

Source:http://beattiesbookblog.blogspot.com

Thursday, October 8, 2009

8th October 2005, 8.50 am

Today is the 4th anniversary of the earthquake that at 8.50 am struck Pakistan's north, from Islamabad to the valleys of Azad Kashmir.


Fatima Bhutto visited the affected areas to record and compile inspiring accounts of those affected—victims and volunteers—as a tribute to their hope, courage and resilience in the face of calamity.The book is titled ‘8.50 am 8th October 2005’

This is what she had to say about her book,
“ There is a dire, ongoing need to recognize and remember that the earthquake didn’t just leave a lot of rubble behind. There are literally millions of people in the need for rehabilitation: physical, emotional, and economic. We urge you to share these stories with as many people as you know, so that you can remind them of the lingering effects of this tragedy, and pave the way for the aid/relief agencies seeking donations, individuals and groups lobbying for international support, and continued financial donations from every individual who is inspired by these stories to continue to help. ”

Here is an excerpt from her book


A TALE OF HUMAN DEFIANCE*
While ordinary Pakistanis have poured massive amounts of relief goods and funds into the earthquake hit areas’ often leaving their schools and jobs behind to volunteer in the relief effort themselves, one finds meager evidence of the state’s presence, writes Fatima Bhutto.

“I arrived in Islamabad on a Friday night. Not being a doctor, engineer, or lawyer, but rather a simple humanities graduate, I was unsure of what I could do for the victims of the devastating October 8 earthquake. The notion of disaster tourism- visiting the site of a catastrophe- always seemed distasteful to me.

I had watched many politicians on TV standing over the bed of a crippled child, head tilted, lips pursed, nodding in overly per formative sympathy and asking inane questions like, “…and beta, were you scared?” or “what did you like studying in school (that is, when you had one?)” and was loath to take part in the disaster tourism charade.

However, when the chance arose for me to travel to the affected areas and donate relief goods to young children and women, I immediately leapt at the chance. I wanted to help in some way but promised myself that I would not belittle the suffering of those victims by acting like a peeping Tom with a predilection for calamity.

I hadn’t been to Islamabad in several years and, upon driving through the city, I was surprised at how normal it all seemed. Islamabad was as antiseptic as it had always been. I bit my tongue and stopped the disaster tourist inside me from asking where on earth all the rubble was, and from seeking directions to the now infamous Margalla Towers.

Over the next few days, as we drove closer to Balakot, through affected areas like Mansehra, the normalcy disappeared. There was the cruel and ironic, the banal, and the uplifting, all in one place. Pakistan is at the best of times filled with contradictions, which are magnified tenfold by occurrences of the extraordinary. Outside Balakot a sign advertising a picnic area read “Heaven’s Spot”. There were no picnickers’ present, of course, as “Heaven’s Spot” is now littered with the remains of human life. The wreckage of the earthquake was not being removed by bulldozers or cranes, it was being captured by the ubiquitous camera phones, which I witnessed many bystanders using to survey the damage around them.

Perhaps, denied the opportunity or the chance to help, our next human instinct is to record. Perhaps those pictures would educate the world to the plight of the earthquake victims and play a part in shedding light on the tragedy of the earthquake.

In fact, while ordinary Pakistanis have poured massive amounts of relief goods and funds into the area, often bravely leaving their schools and jobs behind to volunteer in the relief effort themselves, one finds meager evidence of the state’s presence in the affected areas. There were, however, large ostentatious camps set up by various political parties, which one might have welcomed save for the large and often goofy posters of their respective political leaders-reeking of political mileage- receiving all the injured that sought their aid. I was little comforted by the large billboard near Balakot with our embattled president’s image on it, arms outstretched and brows furrowed, exclaiming “Let’s build a semi-permanent village!” the banality of the statement was disconcerting. Why not a permanent village? Why not total reconstruction, and not the semi-permanent kind?While there are so many questions to be asked, and while this may not be the time to point accusations, when will we get some answers?


There are a lot of questions such as why a country on a rather prominent fault line hadn’t built the necessary civil organizations to cope with an earthquake? Or why, with all the investment we have spent on military and nuclear gadgets, Pakistan is almost totally dependent on foreign expertise, foreign aid, and foreigners to save the wounded? And then there are the thousand and one smaller questions which have been asked and still remain unanswered.

Before leaving the town, once all the goods we had brought were distributed and received, our car had stopped by a roadside and, as I was leaning out of the window, a young girl- no older than seven or eight- smiled and waved at me. I waved back and she came over to the car and spoke to me and my family. Her name was Ulfat, and luckily she and all the members of her family had survived the quake but were rendered homeless. We spoke for a while and when it was time to go, having nothing else on us at the end of a long journey except some candy, we passed Ulfat the bag of sugary sweets wishing we had something more useful, something more permanent to give her.The moment our hands parted a swarm of young boys descended upon her and tried hungrily to take her sweets when an old man, himself injured and living in the camps, moved towards the children and told them “Don’t steal, don’t steal…”

Though I was hesitant about embarking on what I had perceived as “disaster tourism”, I left Islamabad not entirely sure of how meaningful my small contribution might have been for those robbed of their shelters and their loved ones. I was, however, completely emboldened by the courage and awe-inspiring spirit of those that I had met. The resilience of the Pakistani people is surely unparallel and that is something that no one can detract from.

In Balakot there are fruit stands operating under the remains of all but collapsed buildings, a small mark of human defiance against all the odds. There are freshly filled coffins, not measuring more than three feet long, being tended and watched by the old who want nothing more than to bury their children with the grace that they deserve, because truer than the inevitability of death is the fact that for the living, life must go on. And in Balakot it does, and with the utmost human dignity imaginable.”


Continue to support and encourage Fatima Bhutto, please BUY the book
Buy from here .Also profits & royalties from the sale of this book will be donated to the children affected by the earthquake


Today, do keep the families of those that suffered in that quake, in your prayers and if possible help those that strive all their life to help the needy and the neglected.

You can make a donation here to The Edhi Foundation
Edhi foundation is the most trusted name in Pakistan when it comes to relief work within distressed areas in Pakistan and the rest of the world.Edhi foundation is a NON Profit organization that has been in the business of providing social services like medical care, emergency services, air ambulances, burial services, mental habitats, old homes, child welfare services, abused women safe houses and training facilities for the disadvantaged..
Edhi's founder is Abdul Sattar Edhi who established the first clinic in 1951.


Fatima Bhutto is an ardent supporter of the Foundation.


Fatima Bhutto Fan club remembers the victims and families of the quake that occurred in 2005 today, and we have them in our prayers and thoughts.



Regards,
Fatima Bhutto Fanclub Team

* Chapter Copyright: Fatima Bhutto/Oxford Press
Typed for the Fanclub: Fatima Arif

Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Join Fatima Bhutto

Join, Fatima Bhutto fan club Team to help Fatima Bhutto get justice for Murtaza Bhutto. Sign the petition

http://www.petitionspot.com/petitions/justiceformirbhutto/

Join the group and receive continued updates, news and information on Fatima Bhutto.

http://www.facebook.com/search/?q=fatima+bhutto&init=quick#/group.php?gid=140186545282&ref=search&sid=1579075339.2054508579..1

Ubud Writers and Readers Festival 2009

Katie Jacobs in Ubud.


Last night was the unofficial kick off of the Ubud Writers and Readers Festival with a sunset party for early arriving media and writers at the Four Seasons Sayan.The setting itself made it worthwhile attending on a platform in the middle of a huge lotus pond suspended 500m above the valley floor in the middle of a natural jungle amphitheatre.

Thanks to a highly enthusiastic but directionally challenged driver we arrived just as the formalities ended but luckily enough at the same time as Fatima Bhutto; poet, journalist and Benazir Bhutto's niece who I'd noted as my number one hope to meet at the festival.We had a lively discussion on the pros and cons of Facebook (mostly pros) and Twitter (mostly cons) as well the travails of being vegan in Pakistan. She was delightful, open and friendly and very excited about attending as many sessions as she can while she's here.

Everyone then adjoined to The Royal Pita Maha for a traditional Balinese welcome dance and feast in a Royal Balinese garden.

We sat at a table of ten writers from around Asia, including Lloyd Jones, another New Zealand participant, discussing Burma, America's place in the world, Dalmatian wine pioneers and of course cricket

Source:http://beattiesbookblog.blogspot.com


Hydrabad Bar Association Address by Ghinwa Bhutto









Contributed by Marvi

Ubud festival for writers, readers begins


The Jakarta Post , Ubud, Bali | Wed, 10/07/2009 2:18 PM | Headlines

More than 80 writers from 23 countries will again bring their inspiring ideas and voices to the annual Ubud Writers and Readers Festival, to be officially opened at the Ubud Royal Palace.

The opening, with Balinese art and cultural performances, will mark the beginning of the four-day literary fiesta, to be attended by Nobel laureates and international literary figures.

Janet De Neefe, the festival founder and director, said this year's theme is based on the Balinese Hindu words suka duka, meaning compassion and solidarity.

"This deep philosophy will become the main theme of all panels, debates, book launches and other literary activities that will certainly produce thought-provoking discussions," De Neefe said.

Located around 40 kilometers north of Denpasar, the hilly and cool Ubud has long been a haven for local and international artists.

The festival is about connecting communities and celebrating ideas among cultures, de Neefe said.

The four-day event, running from Oct. 7 through Oct. 11, will include discussions, book launches, international publishing forums and writing and editing workshops.

A highlight of the festival is the International Publishing Forum, making its second appearance this year, to be hosted by the Indonesian Publishers Association (IKAPI) together with the Lontar Foundation and the Association of Indonesian Translators.

Noted authors at this year's festival include journalist and writer Fatima Bhutto, the niece of the late Pakistani prime minister Benazir Bhutto. Her book, A History of Bhutto will be published next year.

27th Sept gathering inconnection of Murtaza Bhutto's Anniversary














Contributed by Marvi

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Humor Chic-Fatima Bhutto spell bound in Karachi


Imagine birds flying over the sea at sunset and a light breeze caressing your skin, the intense scent of the sea salt and the deep colour of the blooming bouganville... this is Karachi, the homeland of Fatima Bhutto, the brave journalist and great poet with a rare charm and sweetness.



ILLUSTRATION BY ALEXSANDRO PALOMBO .

Source:http://humorchic.blogspot.com/

Monday, October 5, 2009

Fatima Bhutto is not on Facebook or Twitter, they are fake profiles

ANNOUNCEMENT

We have got official communication from Fatima Bhutto herself that neither is she on twitter nor on other networking sites like Facebook. So please try and spread the word that the profiles are fake and report it to the tweeting and facebook authorities!

Thursday, October 1, 2009

In Havana by Fatima Bhutto

Landing at Havana, you’d be forgiven for swooning. In fact, it’s good form to swoon; the place is so preposterously mythic. A breezy tropical island caught between the Caribbean and Latin America, Cuba is a once in a lifetime destination.


Yes, things are changing-Raul Castro, brother of Fidel, or Commandante- as they call him locally- is opening Cuba up after years of diplomatic and political isolation. The hotels are relaxing their strict laws against the fraternizing of locals and guests. Cell phones are not only legal now but de rigueur-most young Cubans carry not one, but two, just in case-and there is a movement in the National Assembly to pass what would ultimately be the America’s-if not the world’s-most radically liberal gay and transsexual rights law.


But they are not changing too fast; blissfully there is no McDonoalds, no Pepsi Billboards featuring semi-naked pop stars, and Blackberrys do not get reception anywhere on this delightfully socialist island. (Most hotels do offer CNN and MTV round the clock though-there are some things one just can’t escape.)


So, pack your bags and head to Havana. Cart yourself to Cuba, and just go. And when you’re there, this list of ten must do adventures will light your way.


Eat ice cream at the Coppelia: If you don’t know any Spanish, you will do just fine in Havana. Cubans, ethnically shaken and stirred, speak English and a smattering of other languages, but learn this word helado. It means ice cream. And you are not going to find better ice cream anywhere other than this state-subsidized heladeria. Justify it by blaming the tropics-it’s hot , helado helps.


Take a Salsa lesson: Cuban music and dance come alive nightly at the Casa de la Musica, a popular nightspot. Locals line up starting from nine in the evening, and shows run three times a night featuring traditional Afro-Caribbean samba, circus acts and acrobatic salsa and meringue troupes. You’ll never feel good enough to join in, not the way these locals move. The Teatro America right next door, where most of the dancers practice daily, offers lessons for the uninitiated. Professor Gray gives lessons for ten Cuban Convertibles a pop. She’s tough and chain smokes throughout the lessons, but you’ll come away a salsa pro.


Follow the Ernest Hemingway trail: Ernest Hemingway drank his way through Cuba, and it would be suicidal to follow his rum run across the island. But most bars and restaurants in Havana Vieja, or old Havana, have a snapshot of Papa Hemingway taped to the wall or his signature on a faded menu. His favourites were La Bodeguita del Medio, where the mojito was invented, and El Floridita where the frozen daiquiri was born. But be warned, the rum, rona in Havana, is not for the faint hearted; it’s lethal. While you’re at it, sign your name on the wall at La Bodeguita –Salvado Allende has.


Stick your tongue out at el imperio: Despite living under brutal sanctions and diplomatic blockades, Cubans are some of the friendliest people in the world. They’re warm and welcoming to the tourists and eager to share their homes and hearts with their guests (pensiones are terribly popular-forget the five star hotel, stay at a Cuban home with a family ten times more hospitable and a flat rate ten times more affordable), Americans included of course. Film director, Michael Moore, who shot scenes from his health care documentary Sicko in Havana, is a local favourite. Everyone, from cobblers on the road to cinema ushers, has a Michael Moore story they’re eager to share; they love him. But it’s the government of Uncle Sam that remains persona non grata among Cubanos. Several years ago, hot on the “success” of regime changes, the US Special Interests Office-it’s not an embassy, but it’s not a mere office either- ran an LCD screen full of anti-Castro, pro Capitalist propaganda outside their building. In response, Fidel built a ‘wall of flags’ outside the office. Cuba flapping wildly in the wind got in the way of the LCD screen. Just to be sure, Fidel built a salsa stadium in front of the wall of flags. The music’s fantastic at the stadium, and the shows are well worth seeing. The Americans remain, however, unamused.


Book a table at La Guarida: Because you won’t be able to eat there otherwise. La Guarida, a paladar, or local Latin kitchen, is housed in a beautiful old building that seems deserted save for the revolutionary art on the walls and some old woman’s laundry hanging from the second floor balcony, but climb to the top of the building you’ll find yourself walking into a tiny, gorgeously decorated restaurant. Made famous by its appearance in the well-acclaimed Cuban film, Fresa y Chocolate, La Guardia serves exceptional Cuban fare. No beans and rice here. La Guardia, a favourite of visiting celebs like Jimmy Careter and Naomi Campbell, whose pictures hang on the walls, serves the most succulent Tuna with Banana Fufu this side of the equator. No one’s quite sure what Banana Fufu is exactly, but it tastes divine.


Get on a bus and hit the road: Havana’s beaches are stunning, but a six hour bus ride later you’ll find yourself in the United Nations Heritage protected town of Trinidad, right on the island’s coast. Trinidad’s roads are cobblestone, the paladars and pensiones warm and cozy, and the beaches are covered with crystalline white sand. Cayo Blanco, the white(est) key, is a quick boat ride away. Discover Cuba in the heartland. It’s a safe country; renting cars is easy, and the public transport’s a breeze-there’s no excuse not to spend a couple of days trekking outside Havana.


Take in a panoramic view of old Havana: the Saratoga Hotel, a luxuriously renovated hotel, is placed smack in the centre of the old city. The rooftop restaurant Mirador offers a 270 degree view of the city, including the white domed Capitolo, or Capitol building, the Teatro Marti-complete with a neon Viva Fidel sign, several of the older piazzas, and the famous Edificio Bacardi. The Saratoga has panorama in spades. While you swoon, have a café frijol- Havana’s espresso-like coffee on ice.


Get revolutionary: Cuba isn’t all Che Guevara T-shirts and anti-Americanism. Havana has a history of resistance and self-determination that’s uniquely Cuban- the Museum of the Revolution, housed in a beautiful French classical building, is the first place to acquaint your-self with Cuban history. Then take the road less travelled and pop yourself into one of the many street museums n Havana Vieja-small spaces focusing on particular battles or revolutionary heroes. Learn more about current political issues, like the case of the Cuban Five-whose names and faces are painted on walls, posters and pamphlets-by checking out w: freeforgive.org, a site with petitions signed by Archbishop Desmond Tutu and other Nobel Peace Prize laureates.


Puff on a Partagas: Cigars are emblematically Cuban as Fidel and mojitos are. Founded in 1865, the Partagas Cigar Company runs tours through their factory daily. There’s an oaky smelling store full of cigars and crazy cigar accoutrements- the family size cigar ashtray, for example- open to the public too. But the best part? The buxom old woman who hand rolls Cigars while singing folk songs by the bar.


Rent a vintage car: Because ogling them just isn’t enough. The city is crawling with classic Fords, Cadillacs, and Chevys in bright colours with motors spruced up and ready to go. It would be a shame not to.


Hurricane season, the bane of summer months, is over. Havana waits for no one-and with tourism reaching fever pitch over the winter months, you’d be ill advised to put Cuba off any longer. Just remember to leave your BlackBerry at home.


Source:E&Wmag Jan 2009

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Program Schedule for Ubud Festival 7-11 Oct

Main Program

9.00 – 10.00 am Festival Opening

Thursday 8 October

2.30 – 3.30
In Conversation:
Fatima Bhutto
Bejan Matur
Chair Stephen McCarty


Friday 9 October

2.15 – 3.30
Writing in the new world: Obama and dissent:
Fatima Bhutto
Antony Loewenstein
Jamal Mahjoub
Chair Michael Vatikiotis

Saturday 10 October

12.30 – 2.00
Writing the Subcontinent:
Fatima Bhutto
Mohammad Hanif
Sushma
Joshi Vikas Swarup
Chair Richard McGill Murphy


SPECIAL EVENTS

fatima

SUNDAY 11 October
12.30 – 15.00
Literary Lunch with Fatima Bhutto and Desi Anwar
Chedi Club

Described as “the bright new star of a revered political dynasty”, Fatima Bhutto is the niece of the assassinated former Prime Minister, Benazir Bhutto, who came to fame after the appearance of her first book, a collection of poems, Whispers of the Desert, written when she was just 15 years old. Fatima Bhutto will discuss her colourful life as a writer, journalist, politician in training and heir apparent to Benazir’s throne with Desi Anwar.

Tuesday 13 October (Outside Bali)
Global voices in Borobudur
The readings and spoken word performances
Fatima Bhutto

Source http://www.ubudwritersfestival.com/
http://www.ubudwritersfestival.com/bhutto-fatima/

Thursday, September 24, 2009

Shanghai Trip of Fatima Bhutto

3:00pm | Full House Glamour Bar is a full house of international accents as people settle into the seats, couches and even hop onto stools by the bar (grab a mid-afternoon drink) prepare to listen to the conversation between Fatima Bhutto and Geoff Dyer.

3:18pm | Welcome Geoff Dyer of the Financial Times introduces journalist Fatima Bhutto, who will discuss the current situation in Pakistan.

3:25 | Disappearing Bhutto states that "disappearing" has risen, much as it occurred in various countries in South America in the 70s, 80s and 90s. The term disappeared, developed in South America in relation to forced kidnappings and murders literally means "to cease to exist." She discusses several cases and shares one recent story in particular. "In November of 2007 I was in Baluchistan, and I went to visit a family whose son had disappeared. Babusa Milani, 28-year-old university graduate in sociology. He became active with the Baloch National Party. He was disappeared when he set out for the park at 3pm in the afternoon. The family did some amazing things. They held vigils, his nieces held street marches in their neighborhood. Finally after all this posturing, they found that he had been located in one of the prisons." Bhutto says that, because of the women who came out in protest, because of the media clubs, because of the public movement, she received word as she boarded the plane to come to Hong Kong and Shanghai, that Milani had been released.

3:35 | U.S. Realizations Bhutto says that "we have to remind people that we are a young state." Pakistan has only been independent for a little over 60 years. Having just recently broken free from the yolk of colonialism, they're not about to willfully allow another foreign power to take over. "America needs to understand this," says Bhutto.

3:37 | It Comes from the People People have been reappeared, but not through the government, through the people. Babusa Milani's 8-year-old niece was part of mobilizing the children. But, she says, Musharraf has to be given some credit for opening the media. "Before Musharraf you just had state TV. And anyone who's had state TV knows that that doesn't make for great viewing," she says. "That's been amazing. Now, when the government wants to silence the press, they can. But you find that almost instantly they'll start broadcasting on the internet. You can't stop people from gaining access to the internet (and YouTube). The media is an incredibly hopeful attitude."

3:40 | Women with Beards Says Bhutto, "I know people think that women in Pakistan all have beards and are not very political but the women in Pakistan are some of the most politically active and courageous." Bhutto relates the story of Mukhtar Mai, a divorced woman (something taboo in Pakistani society), who was gang raped by a group of feudal lords. When she complained they told her that her family would be threatened. But she said, "shove it" and she filed a police report. In a country where violence against women is something you don't really talk about, she said "No" and she fought this. She went to the media, internationally, and across Pakistan. Does she end violence against women? No, but she's changing a culture. And other women are coming out now and speaking out.

3:45 | Is it Hard to be a Bhutto? "A name is just a name," says Bhutto. "If it changes, it doesn’t change who I am … when I wake up, I don’t say, 'oh, I’m a Bhutto – it’s going to be a good morning.'" "Apparently you can change them [your name] now too," Bhutto quips.

3:46 | The Dynasty As Dryer continues the questions about her family, Bhutto explains that, “we have different political beliefs and to be perfectly honest, having lived in a dynasty and seeing what dynasty can do with a country, I think it’s an unsophisticated and it’s a bit like monarchy." Bhutto continues that, "Dynasties can be stifling and I don’t think their productive. If we’re serious about the democratic process, it has to be opened up and advancement has to be done on merit ... I can’t pack my bags and move out of dynasty land but I can make a choice and I won’t support a process I don’t believe in."

3:48 | On Violence "If anything Pakistani people are survivors, they have the most resilient spirit I've ever seen. When it gets violent we keep going, just more carefully," says Bhutto, whose own family has seen a fair amount of violence over the years. On the rash of suicide bombings in the last while, Bhutto says, "It's important to remember we don't have a history with this. It's only since the War on Terrorism that we've started to see this." Some violence will be done, people will die, and that's all. There's no declaration by the bombers presented, so people are wary of who this person is, is the threat really gone.

3:51 | Islam and Democracy Asks Dyer, "Is Islam incompatible with democracy?" No, says Bhutto. "In Pakistan, Islam is not the problem. Poverty is the problem. Corruption is the problem, incompetence is the problem. There's an over-simplicity in media, it's easier to say it's Islam. In Egypt, Islam is not the problem, corrupt government is the problem."

3:54 | Women and Islam She says, as a Muslim woman, "if you're aware of your rights, it's hard for someone to put you down." Bhutto says that there are many rights for women afforded in Islam, whether they are granted is a different story. Drawing on a symbol usually rallied around in the West as a sign of oppression, she says that the only time she says she properly used the traditional Islamic hair covering was on the subway on her way to the festival, because it was cold.

3:57 | Pakistan and China Bhutto explains that Pakistan and China historically have had a god relationship. Bhutto cites the earthquake in 2005 when, "we relied very heavily on foreign aid and expertise." Although many countries, she says, donated doctors and aid money, the "two countries that were serious and that stayed for more than a month were China and Cuba." With respect to her trip to Shanghai, Bhutto says that, "Coming here to China, I see we [in Pakistan] don’t have the slightest clue about China though … it’s an enormous country … we need to have more interaction between the Pakistani and Chinese people for a better understanding of each other."

4:00 | Pakistan and India In response to a question about why India's development has excelled more quickly than Pakistan, Bhutto reminds the audience that they are two separate sovereign countries and that Pakistan has, unlike India, been under military rule for a long time and India has not been although the people view each other as siblings." Democracy is due but, "Pakistan wants democracy that's theirs, not Indian or American," she says. "We had it in the past and we can do it again."

4:11 | Freedom of Speech Former City Weekend intern, Cameron Willard, pops the question about what Bhutto thinks about the publication of Danish cartoons that are openly racist towards Islam and the conflict between freedom of the press and racism. Says Bhutto, "Freedom of speech is very different than hate speech."
Says Bhutto in response to a question about the American point of view given the border situation with Afghanistan, "Pakistan and Afghanistan got along well with each other. The problem is not the porous border between the two nations, the problem is the American involvement." Bhutto also notes that this isn't the first time that Pakistan has been asked by the U.S. to act as a conduit for their military incursions into the Middle East. Clearly, Bhutto feels that military incursions are largely responsible for the destabilization and problems of the region.

4:12 | Take to the Streets An audience member asks, "You say that hope will come from the people and the media … why don’t people take to the street? When will people fight back and do something?" Bhutto responds, "Pakistani people are hungry and dispossessed." Bhutto relates a story of when she was helping to run a medical camp in a city where, "there’s only one government hospital and government is reluctant to provide for the people. If you need medical care, you have to pay for private care, which is exorbitant for most people ... Since the government hospital is so far, most of the children have scabies since they cannot afford the treatment ... At the camp all the doctors were volunteers and all medicine was donated." After treating a woman at the camp, she woman came back an hour later with her son. Bhutto said it was clear the child had polio, but the woman had no idea, only that her son was sick and had been that way since he was a child. Bhutto used the story to explain that, "You have a population without basic access to services. People have no strength to fight theses mammoth fight. It's not a coincidence that there are no government hospitals … in one province the price of bread went up 900 percent in one month, when you have to think about that, it’s difficult to fight the machine."

4:15 | Static Stopper Problems with the sound system ... Michelle looks a bit frustrated with technology as she converses with a few of the M staff on how to quickly fix the problem. A few moments later, problem solved.

4:22 | Why Radical Islam? "The answer is simple and frightening," says Bhutto. "There are parts of the country where the government is not visible at all. And what happens is that Islamic parties or organizations will come in and set up a madrassa. And when your choice is to either send your son to a madrassa where he can get a meal and learn or remain illiterate, which do you choose?" Another example Bhutto explains is that of Pakistan after the last earthquake. She says after the earthquake the government had no clue what to do, "but the Islamic party was there within house and set up a tent village to help people. The village has food, doctors and a mosque ... [fundamentalist movements] also do things like provide education for girls ... the government doesn’t do that." Bhutto explains that, "[radical Islam] can be avoided, it can exists as option, but here [in Pakistan] there are no options. This religious movement has been growing in Pakistan for a very long time; this is 20 years of their services and social programs."

4:25 | Princess Fatima Asks M on the Bund's Rob, "As you're a journalist, has anyone ever referred to you as the Princess Diana of Pakistan?" [Fatima laughs]. "No," she replies lightly, "I don't do charity work as such ..." As a humorous afterthought she adds, "I've been called other things but not a princess." Michelle Garnaut breaks off the session saying, "I think it's great to end on a light note."

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Sunday, September 20, 2009

Justice For Mir Murtaza Bhutto

Milan Kundera has said ‘The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetting’

It has been 13 years today that Mir Murtaza Bhutto, an elected member of the parliament was murdered along Ashiq Jatoi, Sattar Rajpar, Shajad Haider Ghakro, Rahim Brohi, Yar Mohammad Baloch, and Wajahat Jokhio as they were returning home from a public meeting on the outskirts of Karachi. And yet their killers still live freely.

All these men, all complicit in the murder Shoaib Suddle, Wajid Durrani,RaiTahir,Shahid Hayat,Agha Jamil,Shakaib Qureshi,Masood Sharif were absolutely absolved of their role and in fact were given promotions in their various posts and departments by the then ruling PPP government. Facts and records in this assassination point out to a hand in the highest level of the government. Nothing however has been done about it in spite of the truth being known.

Where is the justice to all those seven families that have lost their loved ones while their killers fearlessly continue to live in Pakistan and abroad? Fatima Bhutto has constantly and relentlessly tried to keep the issue alive and in the spotlight through the power of her pen. She continues to seek justice for her father and for those that do not have the power to voice an opinion.

Please let your voice be heard no matter which part of the world you belong to.

Martin Luther King has said ‘Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly.’ The guilty have to be punished and let us all come together to fight for justice, not only for Mir Murtaza Bhutto but all those six families, that lost their loved one on that fateful night 13 years ago. We must not allow ourselves to become like the system we oppose.

Let us as free citizens of this world contribute in our own way to demand justice from the current government of Pakistan and get the case on fast track to make the murderers accountable for what they have done. Sign this petition demanding justice immediately for Mir Murtaza Bhutto and his friends killed on 20th September 1996.

  • Petition Justice for Mir Murtaza Bhutto



  • Go sign it and forward it to everyone you know

    By Members of FatimaBhuttoFanClub

    Saturday, September 19, 2009

    Murtaza Bhutto's Murder

    By Fatima Bhutto
    News International


    On September 20, 11 years ago, Mir Murtaza Bhutto, my father and an elected member of the parliament, was returning home from a public meeting on the outskirts of Karachi. He was accompanied by Ashiq Jatoi, Sattar Rajpar, Shajad Haider Ghakro, Rahim Brohi, Yar Mohammad Baloch, and Wajahat Jokhio.

    My family and I were not the only ones waiting for my father. There were 70 to 100 police officers placed yards away from our 70 Clifton residence, including several high-level police officials. Some of the officers were in sniper positions in the nearby trees. The streetlights had been shut, the roads cordoned off, and the guards of the nearby embassies were told to leave their posts and retreat within their premises.

    As the car carrying my father approached our house, they were stopped by a police contingent. When my father exited the car, the police opened fire. All of the seven men were fatally wounded. My father was shot several times, but the shot that killed him was fired execution style on his neck. Ashiq Jatoi was also shot at point blank range at the back of his head. The victims were left to bleed without any medical attention – the aim was murder, after all– under the eyes and ears of the police officers for half-an-hour to 45 minutes. All of the seven men were then taken to different locations, none to emergency hospitals.
    My father was taken to Mideast, a dispensary. I lost my father at midnight that night.

    Benazir Zardari was the prime minister at the time. Her government did not arrest any of the police officers. Her government chose to arrest all the survivors and witnesses, two of whom died mysteriously in police custody. The police remained free.

    In time, they were honorably reinstated to their positions and duly and doubly promoted. The tribunal set up to investigate my father’s murder concluded that the assassination could not have taken place ‘without approval from the highest level of government’. We know what the highest level of government was then and where the highest level of government is today but on this, the eleventh anniversary of my father’s assassination, I want to talk about the senior-most police officers responsible for the murder and the various ways in which they were rewarded for their role in the elimination of Mir Murtaza Bhutto.

    All these men placed themselves at the scene of the murder. All of these men claimed there was an encounter; the tribunal concluded forensically that there was no such thing. It was an assassination. Here are the facts.

    Shoaib Suddle was the deputy inspector-general (DIG) of Karachi at the time of the killing; he was one of the most senior officers at the scene of the crime. In the run-up to the American invasion of Afghanistan, he was promoted to inspector-general (IG) and shifted to Balochistan where he could facilitate Operation Enduring Freedom. Mr Suddle was on the fast track for promotion and after he had secured the Wild West for the Americans, he was made director-general of the National Police Academy (NPA) where he chaired the Police Reforms Committee. Shoaib Suddle, a man charged with murder, handled the police reforms. He is currently heading the committee of the NPA that deals with crimes against women.

    Wajid Durrani, alleged to be the coordinator of the assassination, was the senior superintendent of police (SSP) District South, Karachi, at the time of the killing. Mr Durrani, another upstanding member of the police force, was promoted to additional deputy inspector-general (ADIG). You may remember him from recent news headlines; he is now the DIG Traffic of Karachi and is being taken to task over some recent traffic jams. How just.

    Rai Tahir, who stopped the car and allegedly gave the signal to fire once my father exited the vehicle, was the assistant superintendent of police (ASP) in Clifton in 1996. He was promoted to district police officer (DPO) and moved to the Punjab, where he remains today.

    Shahid Hayat was another ASP from the Saddar district. He was promoted to ADIG, then DPO Thatta, and is now prowling Jinnah airport as the Deputy Director of Federal Investigation Agency (FIA). He handles immigration and passport control.

    Agha Jamil was the station house officer (SHO) of the Napier police station in Karachi and was later promoted to work under his old comrade at the traffic department as a deputy superintendent (DSP).

    If this reads like a laundry list of police corruption, that’s because it is.

    Shakaib Qureshi was the Superintendent of the Police in Saddar. Mr. Qureshi absconded from the country illegally and now lives in London. He is alleged to have been involved in the killing of Ashiq Jatoi, who died with a point blank shot to the back of his head. He is currently working as a lawyer in the offices of Clifford Chance, a firm which calls itself a ‘truly global’ law firm and counts as its values ‘ambition, commitment, quality, and community’. Shakaib Qureshi has never returned to Pakistan to face the charges against him; not everyone is fortunate enough to have deals crafted in their honor.

    Masood Sharif was the director-general of the Intelligence Bureau, which reported directly to the office of the prime minister. In Pakistan, ‘police intelligence’ and ‘law and order’ are uniquely ironic oxymoron. Mr Sharif, once he was honorably absolved of any guilt by the police department in an internal review, retired from his post. He was not promoted as such, but Mr Sharif was absolutely rewarded. He was given a position on the Central Committee of Benazir Zardari’s PPP. Only the chairperson of the party, in this case Mrs Zardari, can induct people into the hallowed and honorable Central Committee.

    These are not the only men complicit in the murder; they’re just the big guns (no pun).

    These facts are all a matter of public record.

    Curiosity impels people to ask about the not-so hidden hand, the highest level of government, so I will answer. Asif Zardari, lifelong senator and current PPP poster boy, now lives in New York City in the Trump Towers apartment complex on Fifth Avenue with his dog Maximillian. In a somewhat magical move, he has been given a position on the board of the Oxonian Society, Oxford University’s networking organization. The president of the Oxonian society, a gentleman named Joe Pascal (joe@oxoniansociety.com), introduced Mr Zardari, who joins CEOs, captains of industry, and Rhodes scholars, as a ‘Pakistani political prisoner’. Someone ought to write to Mr Pascal (joe@oxoniansociety.com) and tell him that murder cases, narcotics cases, and corruption cases worth billions of dollars do not make a Nelson Mandela. I know I will (joe@oxoniansociety.com). Mrs Zardari resides between London and Dubai. She plans to return to Pakistan in one month’s time and be hailed as your next prime minister and Gen Musharraf’s new best friend. Mrs. Zardari is currently being tried in a Swiss court for corruption. There is also a case in Spain’s courts against her for corruption – the evidence was unearthed after the Spanish police were following paper trails after the 2004 Madrid bombings and came across some suspicious looking accounts belonging to Mrs Zardari. Mrs Zardari has numerous corruption cases lodged against her in her own country. There have been allegations that she and her partner stole $1.5 to 2 billion from the Pakistani treasury. She’s on her way back for round three.

    Eleven years later and none of the above police officers were removed from their posts of duty. None of the above police officers upheld their sworn duty, which is to safeguard and protect the citizens of this country from harm.

    Eleven years later they have all been rewarded for their role in the murder.

    Eleven years later we have a court case in which the defense shows no interest because they have no fear that they’ll ever face punishment for their crimes – how many men and women were murdered in extra-judicial killings in Karachi from 1993-1996? Thousands. Check the records.

    My father is only one of those victims. They have killed many more and gotten away with it and they will kill many more so long as violence is politically rewarded and injustice is tolerated by the highest levels of the government.